Recently Updated: 20 min read

Getting Into Gift Guides: Pitching Editors

Getting Into Gift Guides: Pitching Editors

To get a product into a gift guide, give the editor one short note that answers the questions a list line has to answer: who the product is for, what it costs, what it looks like and where to buy it. Nothing guarantees a place in the list, and a paid placement is a different matter that has to be labelled. If you run a small online shop or an e-commerce marketing team, the route is to prepare the product page, work out when the editor builds the list, and then send a short pitch. This is not legal advice.

Example scenario: a greenhouse supplier that sells a windowsill seed-starting kit through its own online shop wants the kit to appear in gift guides written for new gardeners.

Read the guide before you write to its editor

A gift guide is a finished piece of editorial work with its own audience, price band and format. A pitch that ignores those choices reads like a mass mailing. Spend time on the guide first, because that reading decides whether you write at all.

What a published guide tells you

Look at three things in the editor's earlier guides. First, the audience: is each guide built around a recipient, an occasion or a budget? Second, the price band: does the editor stay within one range or mix them? Third, the evidence on the page: does the editor describe testing, link to several sellers, or only list names and prices? The answers tell you what material the editor is likely to want from you.

Table: signals in a guide and what they mean for your pitch

Signal in the guideWhat it suggestsWhat to put in the note
Each entry names a recipientThe editor writes by audienceOne recipient and one occasion for your product
Entries carry a pricePrice is part of the entryCurrent price and currency, with the page that shows it
Entries describe use or testingThe editor values first-hand detailPhotos of use and an offer of a sample on request
Entries link to several shopsThe editor lets readers choose a sellerEvery channel where the product is sold
The guide is dated for one seasonIt will be rebuilt for the next seasonA note on when you will update the product page

Decision rule: write or skip

Practical suggestion: write only when the guide's audience and price band overlap with your product and the editor can ship to the buyers you serve. If the overlap is partial, say the difference openly in the note, for example that your kit costs more than the guide's other entries. If there is no overlap, skip the guide and keep looking. A short list of good targets may serve you better than a long list of poor ones.

What Google's review guidance implies for pitch material

Google's page on writing high quality product reviews addresses writers of reviews and ranked lists, not brands. It still shows what kind of material makes a list entry easy to write. You can read the full text on the Google product reviews page (Opens in a new tab).

Evidence the editor can use

The page recommends evaluating the product from the user's point of view and showing evidence of first-hand use, such as visuals, audio or links that document the experience. It also asks writers to share measurements where they apply, to explain what sets the product apart from competitors, and to weigh pros and cons based on original research. A brand cannot write the editor's review, but it can supply the raw material: clear photographs, honest specifications and an offer of a sample.

Alternatives and several sellers

The page suggests discussing comparable products and saying which suits particular uses. It also recommends linking to useful resources, including more than one seller, so readers can buy from the merchant they prefer. For a brand this means the editor may link to a competing shop or a marketplace instead of your own store. Plan for that rather than asking the editor to link only to you.

Lists that stand on their own

When a writer names a best overall pick or a best pick for a purpose, the page says to explain why, with first-hand supporting evidence. It also says ranked lists should contain enough useful content to stand on their own, and that quality and originality matter more than length. Practical suggestion: give the editor a reason that can be checked, such as a feature the reader can see in your photos, instead of praise the editor would have to take on trust.

Prepare the product page and the image kit

The editor's link is the reader's first contact with your shop. If that page is incomplete, out of stock or showing an old price, the list entry loses value and the editor may drop it at the next update.

Checklist: product page before any pitch

  • Price and stock are current and the product can be ordered today.
  • The page says what the product is, what it is made of and how large it is.
  • Images show the product clearly and carry useful alt text.
  • Delivery and return terms are written on the page or one click away.
  • If the product ships only to certain countries, the page says so.

The image kit

Put the images on one page rather than attaching them. Each image gets a credit line, a short permission sentence, and the product name. State that you hold the rights and that the editor may use the images in the guide with the credit. Give the editor a plain background shot and one in-use shot, because list layouts differ and the editor may need either.

Price and currency

Write the price exactly as it appears on the product page and name the currency. If the price may change before the guide is published, say so and promise a short update. A stale price in a published list helps nobody.

Writing the pitch note

The pitch may be the only message the editor reads, so it has one job: present the product as a fit for a list the editor already writes. Keep it to one screen. Everything else belongs behind a link the editor can open if interested.

The subject line

Say what the message is and which guide it concerns: a product suggestion for the editor's gift guide for new gardeners. Skip exclamation marks, capital letters and superlatives. The product name and the audience are enough.

The body in six lines

  1. One sentence on who you are and which shop you write from.
  2. The guide or article you think the product suits, and why.
  3. The product, its recipient and one distinguishing feature.
  4. Current price and the product page.
  5. The image page with the credit line you ask for.
  6. A sample offer on request, with no expectation attached.

A sample note

Example scenario: the greenhouse supplier writes to the editor of a gift guide for new gardeners.

Hello, I read your gift guide for new gardeners. We make a windowsill seed-starting kit that comes with a tray, a clear lid and labels, and I think it suits someone who has just moved to a place with a sunny window. The product page and current price are linked at the end of this message, and photos you are welcome to use, with a credit line, are on a separate page. If you would like to try the kit, I can send one. Whether to include it is your editorial decision, and the sample is not offered in return for a link or a post. Thank you for your time.

What to leave out

  • Any promise or expectation of inclusion. The editor decides, and a note that assumes otherwise may read as pressure.
  • Boasts about other publications.
  • Offers of payment for a link or a swap of links. Paid placement has its own section.
  • Criticism of competing products.

Example scenario: the greenhouse supplier and a seed-starting kit

Example scenario: the supplier wants its seed-starting kit in a gift guide for new gardeners. The work falls into four phases.

Before the pitch

The supplier reads the editor's earlier guides. Two are built around housewarming and first-garden gifts, which fit the kit; a third lists tools for large allotments, which does not. The supplier writes only for the first two. The kit page gets a current price, a list of what is in the box and a note on delivery, and two photographs, one on a plain background and one on a windowsill, go on a separate page with a short permission sentence.

Pitch week

The note follows the six-line pattern and fits one screen. It offers a sample on request, states that no link or coverage is asked in return and says clearly that inclusion is the editor's call.

After sending

The supplier writes the date, the address and the guide in its log. If nothing arrives, it sends one short reminder and then waits for the next gift season.

When a reply or the guide arrives

A reply goes into the log too. If the guide includes the kit, the supplier checks the entry, the link and the credit line, and thanks the editor.

Timing: reach the editor before the list is built

By the time an editor publishes a guide, the entries are chosen, the images are collected and the structure is fixed. A pitch that arrives after that point may have no place to go. Reaching the editor while the list is still open is the whole point of timing.

Working backwards from last year's guide

Find the date the editor published the same guide last year. Assume the work began well before it, and count backwards to choose a sending window. You cannot know the exact build period, because every publication works to its own schedule. For planning content and links around seasons, see seasonal SEO content and link calendar for campaigns.

Table: planning stages, the question to ask and the evidence to keep (practical suggestion)

StageQuestion to askEvidence to keep
PlanningWhich guides fit, and when did each one publish last year?Dated list of last year's guides
PitchingIs the product page ready and does the note fit one screen?The sent note, send date and address
WaitingHas the price or stock changed since the note went out?Price check dates and any updates sent
ReviewingWas the entry accurate, and what should change next year?Page capture and reply texts

Price and stock between pitch and publication

Weeks can pass between the pitch and publication. If the price or stock changes in that gap, the published entry becomes wrong. Say in the note which date your price applies to, and send a brief update if something changes. A product that sells out and stays in a published list frustrates readers and the editor alike.

Budget for the season

If you are also weighing how much to spend on content and links across the season, seasonal backlink and guest post budgeting for ecommerce sets out the planning questions. Practical suggestion: budget a pitch as time. A paid placement is a separate budget line.

Samples: send one only when asked

A sample is a cost and a disclosure matter at once. When an editor asks to try the product, sending one is reasonable. Offering one in the first note is also possible as long as it carries no strings. Sending an unrequested sample and then waiting for a place in the list builds a false expectation.

Rule for samples

Send a sample when the editor asks, and write in the note that it does not guarantee a place and that no link or coverage is asked in return. Keep the shipment details in your log. If the editor wants to keep the product or send it back, ask and record the answer.

Whether and how the editor tells readers about a free product is the editor's decision, and the brand can support an open process. For links and labelling around free products, see free product reviews: links, disclosure and ethics. Google's spam policies list "sending someone a product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link" among examples of buying or selling links. A sample should therefore not be offered in return for a link or a post.

Checklist: sample shipments

  • The editor asked for it, or you offered it without conditions.
  • The note says the sample is not tied to inclusion and that no link or coverage is asked in return.
  • Date, contents and recipient are in your log.
  • Return or keep is agreed in writing.
  • You have not edited or approved the editor's text.

A publication may sell a spot in a list: a brand pays to appear or to have a link placed. That is separate from an editorial pick, and it brings two separate requirements: how the link is qualified for Google, and what the reader is told.

Google's page on qualifying outbound links says to mark links that are advertisements or paid placements, called paid links, with the sponsored value. It adds that nofollow remains an acceptable way to flag them, although sponsored is preferred. More than one rel value can be listed, separated by spaces or commas, and a plain link needs no rel attribute. The page also says these attributes do not prevent discovery: a linked page may still be crawled through sitemaps or through links on other sites. Read the full text on the Google outbound links page (Opens in a new tab). Google's documentation can change, so check the current page before you apply anything.

The line drawn by the spam policies

Google's spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam, including exchanging money for links or for posts that contain links. The same page says buying and selling links is not a violation as long as they are qualified with a nofollow or sponsored rel value. It also names excessive link exchanges, and partner pages made only for cross-linking, as link spam. The details are on the Google spam policies page (Opens in a new tab).

ArrangementHow the link is qualifiedWhat the reader sees
Editor picks the product on merit and nothing is paidNo rel attribute is neededNo paid label; any mention of a free sample is the editor's choice
Brand pays for a listed spotGoogle prefers sponsored; nofollow is also acceptableA clear statement that the spot is sponsored
Brand pays for a post that contains a linkTreated like other paid links: sponsored or nofollowThe post is labelled as sponsored
Product sent at the editor's request, with no link or coverage askedNo link is requested, so there is nothing to qualify; do not tie the sample to a linkThe editor decides whether to mention the sample
Link swap proposedExcessive link exchange is a Google spam example; avoid itNot applicable

The label for readers

Practical suggestion: when a spot is paid, show the reader a short statement such as sponsored placement. For wording and placement examples, see sponsored content disclosure wording, examples and placement. The label does not replace the rel value, and the rel value does not replace the label. Do not ask for a hidden paid spot, and do not leave it unclear who chose an entry.

Keep paid and editorial separate

A single guide can mix paid and editorial entries. If it does, labelling the paid lines separately helps the reader. If you want no paid placement, leave payment out of your note entirely, and treat any payment offer from an editor as a separate conversation.

Checklist: paid placement

  • If money is paid for a link, does that link carry sponsored or nofollow?
  • Can a reader see that the spot is sponsored without clicking anything?
  • Is the paid entry set apart from the editorial entries?
  • Is any link swap, goods-for-links deal or excessive exchange on the table?
  • Are the agreement, amount, label text and rel value in your records?
  • Can you say who chose each entry?

Gift guides can carry affiliate links. Google's product reviews page says reviews can use affiliate links, with the reviewer compensated by the seller when a reader buys through the link. For a brand, that means the editor's link to your product may run through a commission programme. If you operate such a programme, say so in the note and let the editor choose between a tracked link and your direct product page.

Google's spam policies describe thin affiliate pages as pages whose product descriptions and reviews are copied directly from the original merchant, without added value. The same page says good affiliate sites add value by offering meaningful content or features. Practical suggestion: give the editor detailed product facts to work with, not a finished paragraph to paste, so the entry carries the editor's own words.

If you are not included

A missing entry does not mean the product was unsuitable. The list may have been full, the audience may have differed or the note may have come late. Handling the aftermath calmly keeps the door open for the next season.

The second try

Do not repeat the first message. Add something new: a fresh photograph, a new version of the product or a different product that fits another of the editor's guides. Writing to the same editor again and again can read as pressure. Decision rule: one reminder, one second note with new information, and then wait for the next season.

What to do with each reply

  • The editor includes the product: check the page, thank the editor and update the log.
  • The editor asks for a sample: send it, and keep in writing that it guarantees nothing and that no link or coverage is asked in return.
  • The editor proposes a paid spot: treat it as a separate decision and settle the label and rel value in writing before going ahead.
  • The editor declines or does not reply: thank the editor if there was an answer, send at most one reminder, then wait for the next season.

Your own list page

You cannot make an editor include you, but you can build a gift guide or curated page on your own site. A page organised by recipient or occasion helps visitors, and it gives you an address to share in a pitch. The review-writing principles from Google's page apply to it too: the user's viewpoint, what sets the products apart and alternatives. If the page lists only your own products, say so, and do not present it as independent advice.

Independence of the list

A page promoting your own products is not an independent list. For how a writer of a ranked list should state independence and disclosure, see writing best-of listicles with disclosure, which takes the writer's side, while the topic here takes the side of the brand that pitches.

Keeping a citation log

Once a guide includes your product, the work moves to checking and recording. The log is the asset you carry into the next season.

What to check on the published page

  • Are the product name, price and image correct?
  • Does the link reach the product page, and which rel value does it carry?
  • Is the credit line under the image as you asked?
  • If the spot is paid, is the label visible?
  • Has the editor been told about any later price change?

Table: the log

ItemRecord
GuideTitle, address and publication date
PitchProduct sent, date and address used
OutcomeIncluded, declined or no reply, with the reply text and date or the days you tried
Link and creditLink present, rel value, credit line present
Money and labelIf paid, the amount, label text and its place; plus a note for next season

Staying in touch with the editor

After an inclusion, a short thank-you is enough. Write again only when a new product truly fits the editor's audience, and treat a price or stock update as information, not a request. For other ways of earning editorial placement for a shop, see sponsored content for ecommerce brands.

Mistakes to avoid

Writing to a guide that does not fit

A pitch for a product outside the guide's audience or price band costs the editor time and tells the editor you did not read the guide. Read the guide first and skip it when there is no overlap.

Offering a sample in return for a link or a post

Google's spam policies list sending someone a product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link among examples of buying or selling links. Offer a sample on request, with no link or coverage asked in return.

Quoting a price without a date

Weeks can pass before a guide is published. State the date your price applies to and send a short update if it changes.

Following up more than once on the same pitch

Practical suggestion: send one reminder, and write a second note only when it carries new information.

Leaving a paid spot unlabelled

Google's spam policies list money-for-links without a nofollow or sponsored qualification as link spam. Pair the rel value with a label the reader can see.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose which guides to write to?

Read the editor's earlier guides for the audience, the price band and the evidence each entry carries. Practical suggestion: write only when the guide's audience and price band overlap with your product and the editor can reach your buyers, and skip the guide when there is no overlap.

Should I offer a sample in my first note?

Only on request or without conditions. Google's spam policies list "sending someone a product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link" among examples of buying or selling links, so a sample should not be offered in return for a link or a post. State that it does not guarantee a place.

Who should hold the rights to the images I send?

You should hold them or have written permission. Practical suggestion: put the images on one page with a credit line and a short permission sentence, and say in the note that the editor may use them in the guide with that credit.

What if the guide lists competing products?

Expect it. Google's product reviews page suggests discussing comparable products and which suits particular uses, and linking to more than one seller. Plan for the editor linking to another shop, and give facts that help the editor tell the products apart.

How is a paid spot marked up?

Google's outbound links page says to mark paid placements with the sponsored value and says nofollow remains acceptable. Google's spam policies say buying and selling links is not a violation as long as they carry a nofollow or sponsored value. Show readers a visible label as well. This is not legal advice.

Google's product reviews page says reviews can use affiliate links. The spam policies describe thin affiliate pages, where descriptions and reviews are copied from the merchant, and say good affiliate sites add value with meaningful content. Give the editor facts to work with and leave room for the editor's own words.

Conclusion

A gift guide pitch works when the product page is ready, the timing matches the editor's build period and the note fits on one screen. No place is guaranteed, and a paid spot needs a sponsored or nofollow value on the link and a visible label for the reader. This is not legal advice.

If you want to place editorial content for your shop with publishers, you can look at the guest post packages.

0 Comments

No comments yet for this article.

Post a comment

Please log in to leave a comment. Login