A cold email that asks a publisher for a link or offers a product for review raises two questions before it is sent: does it count as a commercial electronic message in Turkey, and does the recipient have to consent first? According to the Turkish Ministry of Trade announcement dated 15 July 2015, prior consent is not mandatory for commercial electronic messages sent to the electronic communication addresses of recipients who are merchants (tacir) or tradespeople (esnaf). The same announcement draws the limit of that exception: if merchants and tradespeople exercise the right to refuse, no commercial electronic message can be sent to them without their consent. This is not legal advice.
If you run a business based in Turkey, or an agency that does outreach for clients, that limit shapes how a mailing list is built, what each message must show and how fast a refusal has to be processed. The US CAN-SPAM rules are a general principle for comparison and not Turkish law.
Start with the recipient: the addressee decides which rule applies
The exception in the announcement depends on who receives the message, not on how the email looks. A company-run trade magazine, a blogger who runs a sole proprietorship and a membership association newsletter can all publish an editorial contact address, yet the exception in the announcement applies only to recipients who are merchants or tradespeople. The sender therefore needs a record of the recipient class before the first message.
Recipient classes and what the announcement says
| Recipient | What the announcement says | Practical suggestion |
|---|---|---|
| A merchant (tacir) | Prior consent is not mandatory; the right to refuse is preserved | Record the trade name and registry details shown on the site |
| A tradesperson (esnaf) | Prior consent is not mandatory; the right to refuse is preserved | Record the evidence that the person trades as a tradesperson |
| A recipient whose status is unclear | The exception cannot be shown from a record | Hold the contact back until the status is clear |
| A recipient who has refused | No commercial electronic message without consent | Move the address to the stop list |
Keeping a classification record
Practical suggestion: write the classification into the outreach sheet next to the address. Three fields are enough: the status you assigned, the page where the evidence appeared and the date you saw it. A publisher imprint that shows a company name and a registry number is clearer evidence than a first name on a contact form. When the evidence is missing, the safest reading is to leave the exception out of the decision.
What the Ministry announcement covers and what it leaves out
The announcement explains that the regulation was prepared for the application of Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce, which entered into force on 1 May 2015. It sets out the rules for commercial electronic messages sent through electronic communication tools such as phones and computers, namely SMS, email and phone calls, and the obligations of intermediary service providers that supply the electronic environment for them. You can read the original text in the Ministry of Trade announcement (Opens in a new tab).
Senders outside the regulation
The announcement lists five situations the regulation does not cover. They describe the sender, not the recipient.
- Messages that operators under the Electronic Communications Law No. 5809 send to their subscribers and users, solely to promote their own goods and services or their business.
- Messages that foundation universities send to their students and the students' parents.
- Messages that professional bodies with public institution status, associations working for the public benefit and tax-exempt foundations send to their members about the activities of their own commercial enterprises.
- Information messages about broadcasting services that radio and television organisations under Law No. 6112 send to inform and educate the public.
- Messages that the state, local administrations and other public legal entities send to inform the public.
A company that sends link requests to publishers is not one of these senders unless it falls into one of the five descriptions.
Situations where prior consent is not needed
The announcement also lists situations without a prior consent requirement. When a recipient gives contact details so that the provider can reach them, no separate consent is needed for commercial electronic messages about changes, use and maintenance of the goods or services supplied. Messages about an ongoing subscription, membership or partnership, collection, debt reminders, information updates, purchase and delivery, and cases where legislation obliges the provider to give information also need no prior consent. Cold outreach goes to a publisher with whom the business has no subscription, order or contract. Practical suggestion: do not read these situations as covering a first pitch.
Where a pitch email sits
The documentation has no statement on link requests or content pitches as a message type. Practical suggestion: if the message promotes your own product, service or business, handle it as a commercial electronic message and build the refusal line, identity block and records around it. A note that only tells an editor about a broken link on their own page contains no promotion, so keep it short and free of sales language.
| Message type | Content | Practical suggestion |
|---|---|---|
| Review sample offer with a link request | Promotion of your own products | Treat as a commercial electronic message |
| Price list sent to a trade magazine | Offer to sell goods | Treat as a commercial electronic message |
| Correction note about a wrong product name on the publisher's page | Factual note, no promotion | Keep it factual and add no sales sentence |
| Delivery update for an existing order | Purchase and delivery notice | Listed among the situations without prior consent |
The merchant and tradesperson exception, read closely
The announcement says that for commercial electronic messages sent to the electronic communication addresses of recipients who are merchants or tradespeople, obtaining prior consent will not be mandatory. It then adds that if merchants and tradespeople exercise the right to refuse, commercial electronic messages cannot be sent without their consent.
What the exception removes
The exception removes one step: collecting consent before the first message. It does not remove the identity details, the refusal line or the record-keeping that surround the message. A sender who skips consent but forgets the refusal line has used the exception and still missed the rest of the rules.
What it leaves in place
The right to refuse stays with the recipient. Once a merchant or tradesperson uses it, the next message needs consent again. In practice the first message and the stop list are two halves of one system: the first message is sent under the exception, and the stop list protects everyone who uses the refusal right afterwards.
Why a consent request email is not an escape route
The announcement states that a commercial electronic message cannot be sent to a recipient's electronic communication address to ask for consent. An editor who has refused therefore cannot be asked, by email, whether they would like to hear from you again. Practical suggestion: send nothing to a refused address. If the editor starts a new conversation on their own initiative, note the date and the channel in the record.
Decision rule: can the first message go out?
- Is the recipient's status recorded, with a source? If not, hold the message.
- Is the recipient a merchant or a tradesperson? If yes, the announcement does not require prior consent. If not, or if you are unsure, the exception cannot support the send.
- Has the address appeared on the stop list? If yes, send nothing.
- Does the message carry the identity details and the refusal line? If not, add them first.
Identity details every message has to carry
The announcement says that for the party behind electronic commercial communication to be identifiable, the necessary information must appear in that communication. It also requires the nature of promotions and gifts to be stated clearly and the conditions for taking part and benefiting from them to be understandable. An outreach email that offers a free sample or a discount has to make those conditions visible.
What the regulation lists for merchants and tradespeople
The heading or content of a commercial electronic message has to show, for merchants, the MERSİS number and the trade name, and for tradespeople, the first name, surname and Turkish identity number. In addition, depending on the type of communication tool, at least one accessible contact detail of the service provider, such as a telephone, fax or short message number or an email address, has to appear.
A signature block that does the job
Practical suggestion: put a standard block at the end of each outreach email. It carries the legal trade name, the MERSİS number, a telephone number and an email address that receives replies. If an agency sends on behalf of a client, record whose details the block shows, because the agency's name and the client's name are not interchangeable.
- Trade name and MERSİS number, in a visible part of the message.
- At least one accessible contact detail.
- The refusal line, in every message.
- The nature and the conditions of any promotion or gift on offer.
For a sole proprietor, the Turkish identity number is among the listed items. Practical suggestion: decide internally whether and how to display it, and record the reason for that decision.
Refusal in practice: stop list, timing and channel
The refusal provisions turn into concrete work for an outreach team. Each sentence in the announcement maps to a task.
What the announcement requires
- Recipients can refuse commercial electronic messages whenever they wish, without giving any reason.
- When a recipient sends a refusal, the consent for the communication channel used for the notice becomes invalid.
- The refusal has to be possible through the same communication channel the message was sent by, in an easy and free way, and it has to appear in every commercial electronic message sent.
- The service provider stops sending messages to the recipient within three business days from the moment the refusal reaches it.
Building the stop list
- Record the refusal with date and time when it arrives.
- Add the address to one shared stop list used by every campaign and every client.
- Remove the address from any scheduled follow-up queue.
- Write down the date the processing finished.
- If a sending tool or an agency is involved, pass the refusal on and get a confirmation.
Working out the three business days
The announcement starts the count at the moment the refusal reaches the provider. Practical suggestion: set an internal target well inside the three days, and compare every scheduled send against the stop list on the day it runs. A follow-up that goes out after a refusal, even within the three days, leaves the recipient with the impression that the refusal was ignored.
Sample refusal line
Example refusal line: If you do not want to receive emails like this one, reply to this message with the word Stop. Once your request is processed, we will not send you further commercial messages.
A reply-based line fits an email campaign because the refusal travels through the same channel, costs the recipient nothing and sits in every message. Practical suggestion: do not route refusals through a paid number or a form that asks for identity details, since those conflict with the easy and free requirement in the announcement.
The channel link between consent and refusal
Because the announcement ties the invalidated consent to the channel of the notice, a refusal by email speaks to the email channel. Practical suggestion: if you also phone or text the same person, treat an email refusal as covering all channels, since that matches what the recipient expects.
Collected addresses: personal data duties and records
The announcement carries a short personal data provision: the service provider and the intermediary service provider are responsible for the storage and security of the personal data they obtain, and they cannot share it with third parties without the person's prior consent.
What an outreach sheet contains
An editor's name, role and business email address can identify a person, so an outreach sheet is a data record and not only a marketing spreadsheet. Sharing the sheet with an agency, a client or another tool is a separate decision point under the sharing provision. For the questions to settle before handing customer data to an agency, see sharing customer data with an agency: confidentiality and data processor clauses.
Records to keep and why
| Record | Purpose | Practical suggestion |
|---|---|---|
| Page where the address was found | Shows the address came from a published source | Keep the page address and the access date |
| Recipient status and its evidence | Supports the merchant or tradesperson record | Keep a note or image of the imprint |
| Send dates | Shows which message went out and when | Log date and time per message |
| Refusal date and processing date | Shows the three business day duty was met | Keep the two dates in separate columns |
| Stop list | Prevents any further message after a refusal | Keep it searchable and restrict who can edit it |
A stop list creates a small tension: deleting a refused address removes the proof that nothing was sent afterwards. Practical suggestion: keep refused addresses on the stop list with only the minimum data needed to block sending, write the retention period into your own data retention policy and limit access to the list.
Using published addresses only
Practical suggestion: do not guess personal addresses or pull them out in bulk with tools. An editorial address that the publisher posted for this purpose also explains where your record came from.
Agencies and sending tools
The announcement says a provider can send commercial electronic messages to recipients whose prior consent it holds either itself or through intermediary service providers, and that the intermediary has to allow the technical means for the provider to meet its obligations. It also says the intermediary has to show its own brand name, trade name or business name in the content of the messages it sends.
Consent cannot be collected for someone else
Intermediary service providers cannot obtain consent in order to send commercial electronic messages on behalf of others, promoting those others' goods, services or business. An outreach agency should therefore keep its own consent practices apart from the client's outreach.
Put the split of duties in the contract
Practical suggestion: write down which identity details go into the messages, who receives refusals, who processes them, where the stop list lives and what happens to the list when the contract ends. Sending infrastructure needs its own records: for sender authorisation see how to write an SPF record for authorised senders, and for policy rollout see rolling out a DMARC policy from none to reject.
Complaints and penalties as the announcement states them
The announcement says complaints can be filed within three months of the date a commercial electronic message was sent, electronically through the complaint portal on the Ministry's website or by petition to the provincial trade directorates. After the complaints are assessed, the provincial trade directorates apply an administrative fine, as set out in the regulation.
Limits of the announcement
The announcement has no statement on article numbers, a reference to the data protection law or the national message management system known as İYS. The announcement dates from 15 July 2015. Rules can change, so check the current text of the regulation before you rely on any detail.
The three month window and your records
Practical suggestion: keep send logs, refusal records and recipient status evidence available at least for the length of the complaint window. A record deleted earlier than that cannot show how a message was sent if a complaint arrives.
Comparing with CAN-SPAM: a US principle, not Turkish law
The US Federal Trade Commission publishes a compliance guide for businesses on the CAN-SPAM Act. The FTC compliance guide (Opens in a new tab) states that, despite its name, the Act does not apply just to bulk email and covers all commercial messages. It also states that the law makes no exception for business-to-business email. The page carries an August 2023 publication date.
The eight main requirements in the guide
| Requirement in the guide | What the guide says |
|---|---|
| Header information | Do not use false or misleading header information; From, To, Reply-To and routing details must be accurate and identify the sender |
| Subject lines | Do not use deceptive subject lines; the subject must match the content |
| Advertisement disclosure | Identify the message as an ad |
| Location | Include a valid physical postal address |
| Opt-out explanation | Tell recipients how to opt out of future marketing email |
| Subscribers and members | They can opt out of marketing email too |
| Prompt handling | Honor opt-out requests within 10 business days and keep the mechanism working for at least 30 days after sending |
| Monitoring others | Hiring another company to send your email does not transfer your legal responsibility |
The guide adds that the sender cannot charge a fee or require personal information beyond an email address to process an opt-out, and cannot sell or transfer the addresses of people who opted out.
Side by side with the Turkish announcement
| Topic | Ministry announcement (Turkey) | FTC guide (US, general principle) |
|---|---|---|
| Business-to-business messages | No prior consent for merchants and tradespeople; right to refuse preserved | No exception for business-to-business email |
| Time to act on a refusal | Three business days from receipt | 10 business days |
| Refusal route | Same channel, easy and free, in every message | Return email or an easy web method; no fee, no extra personal data |
| Identity of the sender | MERSİS number and trade name for merchants; name, surname and identity number for tradespeople; at least one contact detail | Valid physical postal address |
| Sending through a third party | Intermediary cannot obtain consent for others | Responsibility is not transferred by hiring a sender |
Where the comparison misleads
The two texts do not use the same concepts. The US guide leaves no room for a business recipient exception, while the Turkish announcement removes the prior consent step for merchants and tradespeople. Which country's rule applies to a given send is outside the scope of this topic. What the comparison can offer is shared good practice: a visible refusal route, a fast refusal process and no new message after a refusal.
Deliverability rules versus legal duties
Mailbox providers set their own expectations for senders, and those are separate from the announcement's duties. For the expectations that apply to bulk senders, see bulk email sender requirements for publishers. For unsubscribe handling at header level, see one-click unsubscribe with the List-Unsubscribe header. A header-level unsubscribe does not replace the refusal line inside the message, so plan the two together.
A newsletter that people sign up to is a different system from cold outreach. The consent and privacy setup for it is described in email consent and privacy law: compliant newsletter subscriptions. Carrying newsletter logic into an outreach list, or writing to newsletter subscribers with outreach logic, mixes two record systems.
Worked scenario: a workwear and safety boots shop
Example scenario: a workwear and safety boots shop wants a place in a buyer's guide for site boots. It plans to write to three publications. The first is a trade magazine run by a limited company. The second is a site-safety blog operated by one person. The third is the newsletter of a regional contractors' association. The pitch offers a free sample pair for review.
Step 1: classify each recipient
The magazine's imprint shows a trade name and a MERSİS number, so the shop records it as a merchant with the imprint page as evidence. The blog shows only a first name, so the status stays unclear and the address is held back. The association newsletter shows no sign of a merchant or tradesperson status, so the shop does not rely on the exception for it.
Step 2: write the message with the promotion conditions
The sample offer is a promotion, so the message states the conditions: who is eligible, what the sample is, whether the pair must be returned and whether a review is expected. After the text comes the identity block with the shop's trade name, MERSİS number, a telephone number and a reply address, followed by the reply-based refusal line.
Step 3: handle the answer
If the magazine's editor replies with the word Stop, the shop logs the arrival time, adds the address to the shared stop list, removes the follow-up from the queue and notes the processing date. If the editor later writes first about the boots, the shop notes the new conversation and its date.
Step 4: the agency question
If the shop hands the sending to an agency, the contract states that the messages carry the shop's own trade details, that refusals reach a named inbox and that the stop list stays with the shop when the contract ends.
Checklist by stage
Before sending
- Recipient status and evidence recorded, with page and date.
- Address taken from a published source, source recorded.
- Stop list checked and current.
- Identity block ready: trade name, MERSİS number, one contact detail.
- Promotion or gift conditions written clearly if any are offered.
In the message
- Refusal line visible, free and usable by reply.
- Subject line matches the content.
- No request for consent inside a commercial message.
After sending
- Refusals logged on arrival and processed well inside three business days.
- Scheduled follow-ups compared against the stop list at each run.
- Send, refusal and processing dates kept for at least the three month complaint window.
- Agency or tool handling of refusals confirmed in writing.
Mistakes to avoid
Treating the exception as permanent permission
The exception removes only the prior consent step. A refusal ends the sender's ability to write without consent, whatever the recipient's status.
Building one big list on assumptions
Placing every publisher in one list as a merchant leaves the unclear recipients without any record to support the exception.
Making the refusal harder than the message
If sending the message takes one click and refusing takes a form, a phone call or an identity check, the setup does not match the easy and free requirement.
Leaving follow-ups outside the stop list check
A scheduled sequence that does not read the stop list keeps writing after a refusal.
Quoting US rules as Turkish rules
The 10 business days and the postal address belong to the FTC guide. Turkish details are those stated in the 15 July 2015 announcement; check the current regulation text.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is consent required before emailing a merchant or tradesperson for the first time?
According to the Ministry of Trade announcement, obtaining prior consent is not mandatory for commercial electronic messages sent to the electronic communication addresses of recipients who are merchants or tradespeople. If they exercise the right to refuse, messages cannot be sent without their consent. This is not legal advice.
How long does a sender have to stop after a refusal?
The announcement says the service provider stops sending messages to the recipient within three business days from the moment the refusal reaches it. Practical suggestion: aim for same-day processing and check every scheduled send against the stop list.
Which senders does the regulation leave out?
The announcement lists five situations, among them operators under the Electronic Communications Law No. 5809 promoting their own goods to subscribers, foundation universities writing to students and parents, and the state or local administrations informing the public. A company that sends link requests to publishers is not one of them unless it matches a description.
Does the announcement mention İYS?
No mention of İYS or of the data protection law is covered here. Check the current text of the regulation before you rely on any detail.
How long is the complaint window, and who handles complaints?
The announcement says complaints can be filed within three months of the date the message was sent, through the Ministry complaint portal or by petition to the provincial trade directorates, which apply an administrative fine after assessing them.
Does CAN-SPAM apply to a Turkish business writing to a Turkish publisher?
The FTC guide describes US rules. Where it says there is no exception for business-to-business email, the Turkish announcement instead removes the prior consent step for merchants and tradespeople.
Conclusion
Cold outreach in Turkey comes down to three checks: is the recipient a merchant or tradesperson on record, does the message carry identity details and a free refusal route, and is each refusal processed within three business days? The Ministry announcement lifts the prior consent step for merchants and tradespeople but keeps the right to refuse, and the CAN-SPAM guide is a comparison that offers ideas for refusal handling and records. This is not legal advice.
If you want to run link outreach with a traceable record from publisher selection to placement, you can look at the backlink packages.
Post a comment
Please log in to leave a comment. Login